The state called it “evil design” - the court called it a single honest mistake
An Arkansas teacher lost her job after a five-year-old wandered off to grab crayons - and the state’s highest court just weighed in.
The worker was an art educator at Strong School District. On November 20, 2024, she was walking a group of students between rooms when a kindergartener slipped out of line to retrieve crayons. She didn’t notice. Two to three minutes later, a music educator found the child crying in the art classroom. He was unharmed.
Three weeks later, the district told her by letter she had breached its supervision policy. A hearing followed. She was fired.
She applied for unemployment benefits. Denied. The Division of Workforce Services said she had been let go for misconduct - leaving a child unattended. She appealed to the Appeal Tribunal. Denied again. Then to the Board of Review. Same result.
The Board accepted her explanations: she was rushing because of time constraints, distracted by misbehaving students, and believed the child had come back to the line after she called to him. It also noted she knew she could ask for help with unruly students because she had done so before.
Then came the kicker. The Board found she was “negligent to such a degree as to manifest wrongful intent or evil design.”
Evil design. For missing a kindergartener who doubled back for crayons.
The worker took the fight to the Arkansas Supreme Court, which granted her petition for review. Its job: clarify when a single workplace mistake crosses into misconduct that strips someone of unemployment benefits.
Under Arkansas law, there are two routes to disqualifying misconduct. One is breaking an employer’s behavioral rules. The other is poor performance - but only if the employer proves it was intentional. Intentional poor performance can be shown through repeated failures despite progressive discipline.
None of that fit. The court found nothing in the record showing the worker deliberately left the student alone or willfully ignored the district’s interests. No pattern of repeated negligence. No progressive discipline.
As for the Board’s “wrongful intent or evil design” standard? The court was blunt: that phrase appears “nowhere in the statutory scheme.”
The court also drew a broader line. A routine slip-up against employer expectations does not, on its own, amount to disqualifying misconduct. The statute separates poor performance from intentional poor performance - and that gap matters.
On November 19, 2026, the Supreme Court reversed the Board and sent the case back for an award of unemployment benefits.
For HR professionals managing terminations and benefit disputes, the message is practical: one honest mistake - even in a safety-sensitive role - won’t meet the misconduct bar without evidence of intent, willfulness, or a documented pattern of repeated failures.